In order to better understand the Revolution, it helps to
look at the conditions people were living in at the time. The revolution in Spain did not "just happen". Anarchist
thought and ways of organising had been prevalent there for nearly
seventy years, by the time of the Revolution. There was a healthy
history of persistent anarchist agitation and revolutionary struggle.
Spain had seen a long series of peasant uprisings, insurrections,
industrial strikes, protests, sabotage and other forms of direct action.
It was their direct involvement in these events, that had prepared and
equipped the peasants and workers to organise resistance to the
attempted fascist coup in July 1936 and, when they had defeated it in
the streets, to take control of the economy and all aspects of their
lives.
The old order: private
boxes at the bullring & shoe shining the clergy and police
During the First World War Spain had remained neutral,
which meant large foreign markets for export of agricultural goods,
which, combined with the industrial development in (mainly) Catalonia,
meant a boom time. However, in the 1930's, after the Wall Street crash,
the whole of Europe was experiencing one of it's worst ever slumps. To
make it worse for the Spanish people, Britain and France imposed tariffs
barring their exports. In 1936 one million out of Spain's workforce of 3
million, were unemployed (with no dole!); prices had risen by 80% in the
previous 5 years, and 67% of the land was 'owned' by 2% of the
population. Many workers and peasants experienced major hardship.
The Catholic church was also massively powerful and
corrupt (a third of the land was 'owned' by the Jesuits alone!), with
priests overtly living in luxury while the peasants around them often
starved and were kept illiterate (40% couldn't read or write). It's not
a great surprise, then, that the church was commonly hated..
The C.N.T (Confederacion Nacional
Trabajo - National Confederation of Workers)
The C.N.T was the biggest union in Spain at the time,
with one million members and it's own daily newspaper, Solidaridad
Obrera, (compared to the P.O.U.M, it's nearest rival, who had barely
10,000 members in 1936). Along with it's sister union the F.A.I. (the
Iberian Anarchist Federation) the C.N.T was a revolutionary union,
concerned with the dignity of it's workers as well as their pay. The
strength of the C.N.T and the widespread acceptance of anarchism, cannot
be separated from the structure and tactics of the C.N.T.
The practice of direct action and solidarity encouraged
workers to rely on themselves to sort out their own problems. The
decentralised structure of the anarchist unions had an educational
effect on their members. By discussing issues, tactics, ideals and
politics in their union assemblies, the members of the union educated
themselves and, by managing themselves in their struggles, prepared
themselves for a free society.
Through the C.N.T. anarchists principles were applied in
people's everyday lives, and their effectiveness ensured that they
became commonplace and accepted in a large section of the population. It
showed, in practice, that bosses (capitalist as well as union ones) were
not needed (out of 1 million members there was only one paid
administrator in the C.N.T!). It showed in a very practical way, that
workers can manage their own affairs directly and that anarchist
principles were not utopian. .
Lead Up To The Revolution
In 1931 a coalition of Republicans and Democrats were
elected to power but didn't do much to improve the living conditions for
the vast majority of workers. Unemployment stayed high and the working
class organisations, especially the CNT, suffered repression with many
members being imprisoned. By June 1933 there were 9,000 political
prisoners. This new government refused to take on the industrialists,
landowners, army officers and bishops. It would not stand up to that
minority which owned all the wealth and had all the real power. In the
election of 1933 a right-wing coalition came to power.. The wealthy and
powerful now had state power and were determined to use it to smash
working class and peasant resistance. The right went on the offensive.
Of course, the working class fought back. There were
risings in Catalonia and Asturias. Workplaces were taken over and union
members took up arms against the state. Unfortunately they were isolated
from the rest of the country and were viciously repressed. The massacre
that followed the defeat in Asturias was unprecedented with at least
3,000 being executed. But the spark of revolution had been lit!
In the elections of May 1936, there was a landslide vote
for the left, bringing the social democrat government of Largo Caballero
to power.
The Attempted Fascist Coup
At the same time Moroccan revolutionaries were preparing
to kick out Spanish colonial rule and had the support of the C.N.T. All
they lacked was arms. The French Popular Front ("socialist") - the only
ones in a position to provide the arms to do the job - refused point
blank to do so, and this left the way open to Franco, famed for his
viciousness as a general, and his army of fascists, who launched a
putsch in Morocco in July 1936, then moved north into Spain .Those in
power planned to strike a deal with Franco, which was only smashed by
the activity of the organised working class.
Civil War
In certain parts of the country, the fascists made some
headway, largely because the government hesitated in responding, and
there was little opposition. Andalusia was captured by Franco's troops
and by July 21st, a third of the country had fallen. But in Catalonia,
and especially in Barcelona, the workers of the CNT showed how to
fight! They declared a general strike and took to the streets looking
for arms which the government refused to give them. In the end they
stormed the barracks, and took what they needed. They were aided by
soldiers who had remained loyal, some of whom turned their guns on their
officers.
There is absolutely no doubt that the initial response to
Franco's coup was determined by the fact that the CNT and its anarchist
ideas held sway among large sections of the working class. There was no
waiting around for government ministers to act, the workers took
control. Anarchist influence could be seen in the formation of the
militias, the expropriation and reorganisation of the land, and the
seizures in industry.
Workers joined the militias because they wanted to. They
understood the need to fight and the necessity of creating a "popular
army". They accepted discipline not because they were told to but
because they understood the need to act in a co-ordinated manner
The Durruti column (part of the anarchist militias), for
example, showed how to fight fascism. They understood that a civil war
is a political battle, not just a military conflict. As they gained
victory after victory they encouraged peasants to take over the land and
collectivise.
At the time of the election, it should be remembered, the
Spanish Communist Party was barely existent, but in his efforts to
counter the libertarian forces, Stalin, who provided (and crucially,
controlled the distribution of) arms, practically imported a ready made
party which gained positions of control and influence.
Although everyone who saw the militias in action had
nothing but praise for the heroism they witnessed, the government made a
deliberate choice. It chose to starve the revolutionary workers of arms.
It decided that defeating the revolution was more important than
defeating fascism!
George Orwell (who fought in one of the POUM militias)
described the arms situation on the Aragon front. The infantry "were far
worse armed than an English public school Officers Training Corps, with
worn out Mauser rifles which usually jammed after five shots;
approximately one machine gun to fifty men (sic) and one pistol or
revolver to about thirty men (sic). These weapons, so necessary in
trench warfare, were not issued by the government.... A government which
sends boys of fifteen to the front with rifles forty years old and keeps
its biggest men and newest weapons In the rear is manifestly more afraid
of the revolution than the fascists".
To stack the odds against the working class
revolutionaries of Spain even further, is the fact that Hitler and
Mussolini were providing massive numbers of troops, tanks, planes etc to
kill off the Revolution (though, officially they weren't even there!).
They were using Spain as a dress rehearsal for the 2nd world war. In
February 1937, there was a total of 50,000 Italian troops in Spain,
fighting alongside Franco's! One of Franco's officers was even quoted as
saying "What won the war for the nationalist army was it's superior
artillery and bombing capacity (both provided by Germany and Italy). You
could say the Condor Legion won the war "
The Social Revolution
In 1936, although the Popular Front government still
existed it had no power. It was shorn of the repressive organs of the
state. Power was split into countless fragments and scattered in a
thousand towns and villages among the revolutionary committees that had
taken control of the land and factories, the transport and communication
systems, the police and the army. The military, economic and political
struggle carried on independently of the government - or rather, in
spite of it!
Everywhere change was apparent. The whole character of
the country changed. Posh restaurants no longer existed. Collective
eating houses took their place. A spirit of comradeship was in the air.
This was much more than a civil war - this was the social revolution!
The role of women changed. They were in the militias and
fought alongside the men as equals. They were organising the collectives
and taking up the fight.The Anarchist women's organisation, Mujeres
Libres (Free Women), had 30,000 members. It had been active before the
Civil War organising women workers and distributing information on
contraception. During the war abortion was legalised in the 'republican
zone'. Centres were opened for women, including unmarried mothers and
prostitutes.
In some of the places controlled by the C.N.T. money was
abolished, all resources were colletivized with factories and buses
emblazoned with the notice "Incautado" (impounded). The workers were now
in control!
They had no one to rely on but themselves, and the people
understood that. When harvest time came, people were mobilized street by
street, the crops being mainly used to feed the fighters at the front.
Production was sharply stepped up everywhere, which, when we consider
the conditions in which this was happening, is something of an economic
miracle! Collectivisation was working!
Workers in the fields
rise while churches are bricked up!
The people established their own schools and maternity
services; they overhauled the medical services and the gas, water, power
and railway services. In Villajoyosa, they built a dam to bring water to
a million almond trees! For the first time ever, the Spanish tram system
was working properly, the trams painted red and black - the colours of
the Revolution!
Freedom Denied
From the moment of Stalin's intervention, with supplies
of arms ( all of which were paid for in Spanish gold, and precious few
of which actually made it to the fighters at the front!) the writing
was on the wall for the Revolution. With the Russian Communists just a
short time away from signing an agreement with Hitler and supplying arms
to Mussolini for his invasion of Abyssinia, Stalin's grip over the
Spanish Republican government grew and grew. He gradually won over the
richer farmers and the moderate bourgeoisie and counter-revolutionary
influence took hold. In December, Pravda announced that "in Catalunia
the mopping up of Trotskyists and anarcho-syndicalists had already
begun"!
In May 1937, after weapons had been completely withheld
from Catalonia, the Communists and the right launched their decisive
attack on the anarchists and the socialist POUM. After a week of
ferocious fighting, which left 500 dead and 1,000 wounded, the C.N.T
were driven out of the telephone exchange in Barcelona. The government
sent in 6,000 men to disarm the workers, and, effectively, that was that
for the revolution - except, of course for the slaughter, torture and
repression that followed!
Efficiently organised as the Spanish anarchists had been,
this cannot change the fact that Franco's forces and the Communists had
access to more and better weapons!
If you tolerate this
then you're children will be next...
Conclusions
The scale of the achievements and the many
successes of the Spanish The Revolution speak loud of the both the
heroism of the Spanish workers and peasants, and of the fact that
anarchist forms of organisation - direct action, solidarity and
self-management - are not utopian dreams but effective ways of living
and working.
We must never forget that the people of Spain had to
struggle against enormous odds - from the obvious, ie Franco and his
forces, and the thousands of troops and weapons provided by Mussolini
and Hitler, to the less obvious, Stalin's attempts to remove the
libertarian nature of the revolution; and the lack of support from
neighbouring 'social-democratic' governments,
In the words of Noam Chomsky, the Spanish Revolution was
"maybe the most successful example of people taking their lives
into their own hands" .
Antonia Fontillas, a woman who participated in the
Spanish Revolution, has this to say:- "We supported the concept of
loyalty, honesty. Those are the basic concepts of anarchism.....after
all, it's about breaking down barriers; not to be subservient and fight
to become decent men and women for our own dignity......i think it is
our mission as men and women, to defend our dignity, our right to be,
our freedom either as a collective group or as an individual."